ARTICLE OF THE DAY

20/11/2026

No... the Neanderthal was not a primitive ape

How a cave changed our view of Neanderthals

Reconstructed skull from Shanidar 1 - wikimedia

Shanidar Cave is one of those archaeological sites crucial to our humanity. We are in northeastern Iraq, in the Iraqi Kurdistan region. Thirty-five Homo sapiens burials and 11 Homo Neanderthalensis skeletons have been found inside this cave.

This continuity demonstrates how the cave served a ritual function over millennia, demonstrating that Neanderthals possessed a cognitive thought linked to sacredness. The significance lies not only in the act itself but also in the paleoanthropological evidence that has emerged. Who were these individuals and why did they choose Shanidar?

Neanderthals lived between 400,000 and 24,000 years ago (subject to new dating and discoveries), between Europe and the Middle East. They had a cranial capacity of between 1,300 and 1,600 cubic centimetres, a very pronounced brow ridge, very thick jaws and teeth, and greater strength and musculature than ours. During the Pleistocene, the climate in the Kurdistan area alternated between arid and temperate phases. The flora offered oak trees and wild pistachios, while the slopes of the Zagros Mountains contained vast grasslands that yielded grasses, wild legumes, and archaic cereals. This was the ideal environment for the large mammals hunted by these hunter-gatherers.

The cave reveals a unique anthropological aspect: analysing the skeletons of Shanidar 1 and 4, we found ourselves faced with an empathetic social group that offered medical care and voluntarily buried the dead.

Shanidar 1, a 40-45-year-old male (an elderly man for the time), showed very serious pre-mortem injuries: trauma to the forehead and left eye that left him partially blind, and a violent blow to the right side of his body. This caused severe deforming arthritis in his knee and ankle, broke his foot, and caused multiple fractures and atrophy of the clavicle, scapula, and humerus, leading to a probable amputation of the arm. He would not have survived the Pleistocene era immediately after the impact, yet the group cared for and protected him.

Shanidar 4 was removed in a single block of earth and excavated in the laboratory, revealing two other adults and the vertebrae of a newborn. The pit was intentionally dug and surrounded by stones, revealing a significant pollen presence in the sediments. Initially interpreted as grave goods, we now know they were brought by rodents.

The importance of Shanidar remains undeniable: a community that protected the weak and created intentional tombs where they returned periodically to lay their dead.



Bibliography:

E. Trinkaus, in The Shanidar Neanderthal, Accademic Press, New York, 1983

Website: F. Dorey, in Homo Neanderthalensis – The Neanderthal, in Australian museum, 28 giugno 2021 (consulted June 2026)

Website: F. Lewsey, in Shanidar Z What did Neanderthals do with their dead, in University of Cambridge (consulted June 2026)

Author:

 Matteo Morea

Publication date:
20/11/2026
Translator:
Paola Manunta